Notre Dame Defeats SMU 24-3 as Defense Turns Away Mustangs at the Goal Line
CJ Carr threw for 312 yards and Notre Dame's defense stopped SMU deep in its own territory four times in a 24-3 win at Notre Dame Stadium.
SOUTH BEND, Ind.: SMU moved the ball against Notre Dame for much of Saturday night. It just could not finish anything. CJ Carr threw for 312 yards, Nolan James Jr. ran for 98 yards and a touchdown, and Notre Dame's defense repeatedly stopped the Mustangs inside its own territory in a 24-3 win at Notre Dame Stadium.
The Fighting Irish (10-1), No. 6 in the College Football Playoff rankings and No. 3 in the AP Top 25, finished 6-0 at home and have won all four games since Oct. 31, a stretch that included a 31-24 victory over Miami on Nov. 8, per ESPN results. SMU fell to 7-4 overall and remains 5-3 in Atlantic Coast Conference play.
Why it matters
Notre Dame plays as an independent, so it has no conference championship game to add to its resume. That makes every regular-season result part of its playoff case, and Saturday added a comfortable home win over a seven-win ACC opponent. The Irish close the regular season next week at Syracuse before the committee's final rankings in December. The next rankings release is Tuesday, Nov. 24.
For SMU, the loss was its third in four games, following a 30-27 defeat at Syracuse on Oct. 31 and a 49-7 home loss to Wake Forest on Nov. 14, according to ESPN results. The Mustangs' only win in that span was a 51-28 victory over Virginia Tech on Nov. 7.
A sloppy start, then a 99-yard answer
SMU nearly opened with points. Kendrick Raphael broke a 70-yard run on the second play of the game, and the Mustangs reached the red zone, but a botched snap on a field goal attempt left them empty-handed, according to WNDU-TV in South Bend.
Notre Dame gave the ball right back when Jordan Faison fumbled, his second lost fumble in as many games, WNDU reported. The Irish defense forced a three-and-out, and SMU's punt pinned Notre Dame at its own 1-yard line.
From there, Notre Dame went 99 yards in 11 plays. Carr hit Jaden Greathouse for a 62-yard gain to flip the field, and tight end Cooper Flanagan finished the drive with a 2-yard touchdown run with 1:49 left in the first quarter for a 7-0 lead, per the ESPN scoring summary.
Notre Dame builds a halftime cushion
SMU answered with its most patient drive of the night, a 16-play possession that used 7:59 of clock and ended in Brendan Baird's 40-yard field goal, cutting the margin to 7-3.
The Irish responded with a seven-play, 75-yard drive in the second quarter. Carr found Faison for a 21-yard touchdown on a one-handed catch in the end zone, WNDU reported, and Notre Dame led 14-3.
SMU drove back into scoring range, but Jayden Sanders intercepted a Kevin Jennings pass in the end zone. After a Notre Dame punt and an SMU three-and-out, the Irish moved 63 yards in five plays in the final 26 seconds of the half, and Spencer Porath made a 32-yard field goal with two seconds left for a 17-3 halftime lead, according to ESPN drive data.
James extends the lead
Notre Dame took the second-half kickoff and scored again. James ran for 38 yards to the SMU 15, and two plays later he finished a seven-play, 75-yard drive with a 4-yard touchdown run at 11:31 of the third quarter. The score gave James a touchdown in all 11 games this season, according to WNDU, and made it 24-3.
That was the final scoring of the night, but SMU had chances to make it closer. The Mustangs drove 78 yards in 11 plays late in the third quarter before turning the ball over on downs near the Notre Dame goal line. Notre Dame gave the ball back when Jayvon Thomas intercepted Carr on the first play of the fourth quarter, per ESPN play-by-play. Later, SMU went 85 yards in 14 plays and again came away with nothing on downs inside the Notre Dame 5. Notre Dame then ran out the final 4:20.
Key performances
Carr completed 19 of 29 passes for 312 yards with a touchdown and an interception, averaging 10.8 yards per attempt. Faison caught seven passes for 109 yards and the touchdown, Micah Gilbert added three catches for 58 yards, and Greathouse's lone reception went for 62 yards. James carried 15 times for 98 yards, and Jonaz Walton added 49 yards on 13 carries.
Defensively, Joey O'Brien led Notre Dame with seven tackles, Boubacar Traore had 2.5 tackles for loss, and Adon Shuler and Elijah Hughes each recorded a sack. Sanders' end zone interception was the defense's only takeaway, but the unit's work on fourth down and in the red zone defined the night: SMU converted two of five fourth-down attempts and six of 17 third downs.
Notre Dame lost two players to injury in the first half. Safety Luke Talich and receiver Greathouse were both ruled out for the rest of the game, WNDU reported. Their status for next week was not immediately known.
For SMU, Jennings completed 24 of 45 passes for 216 yards with an interception. Yamir Knight caught nine passes for 115 yards, and Raphael finished with 100 rushing yards on 12 carries, 70 of them on the game's second play. Linebacker Alexander Kilgore made 12 tackles.
Key stats
- Final: Notre Dame 24, SMU 3
- Line score: SMU 0-3-0-0 (3); Notre Dame 7-10-7-0 (24)
- Total yards: Notre Dame 464, SMU 327
- Passing: Notre Dame 312 (19 of 29), SMU 216 (24 of 45)
- Rushing: Notre Dame 152 (35 carries), SMU 111 (25 carries)
- First downs: Notre Dame 21, SMU 18
- Third down: Notre Dame 5 of 9, SMU 6 of 17
- Fourth down: Notre Dame 1 of 1, SMU 2 of 5
- Turnovers: Notre Dame 2, SMU 1
- Time of possession: Notre Dame 31:14, SMU 28:46
What it means for Notre Dame and SMU
Notre Dame's case for a playoff spot rests on a 10-1 record, a head-to-head win over Miami and a defense that has allowed 10 points across its last two games, 7 to Boston College and 3 to SMU, per ESPN results. Saturday added another example of that defense holding firm when an opponent reached scoring range.
SMU is still bowl eligible at 7-4, but its slide since late October has removed it from the top tier of the ACC race. Miami and Wake Forest have already claimed the two spots in the ACC Championship Game.
ECSL's pregame breakdown is available in our SMU at Notre Dame preview.
Up next
Notre Dame closes its regular season at Syracuse next Saturday, Nov. 28. SMU travels to Stanford the same day, per ESPN schedules.









