No. 3 Miami Outlasts Florida State 43-35 in Double-Overtime Thriller Behind Malachi Toney's Heroics
MIAMI GARDENS, Fla. — No. 3 Miami survived one of the most dramatic games of the 2026 college football season Saturday night, defeating rival Florida State 43-35 in double overtime at Hard Rock Stadium to preserve its undefeated record.
Sophomore wide receiver Malachi Toney delivered 154 receiving yards, two touchdowns and the decisive two-point conversion pass, helping the Hurricanes escape a relentless challenge from their in-state rivals.
Quarterback Darian Mensah threw for 326 yards and three touchdowns, while running back Javian Mallory added 108 rushing yards and two scores.
Miami improved to 6-0 overall and 4-0 in Atlantic Coast Conference play. Florida State dropped to 3-4 and 1-3 in the ACC despite an impressive performance from quarterback Ashton Daniels.
The victory strengthened Miami's case for the nation's No. 1 ranking after Georgia and Notre Dame, the two highest-ranked teams entering the weekend, suffered defeats.
Malachi Toney Delivers Game-Winning Performance
Toney emerged as Miami's most important offensive playmaker, finishing with 11 receptions for 154 yards and two touchdowns.
He also contributed 31 rushing yards and eight punt-return yards, giving him a game-high 193 all-purpose yards.
His biggest moments came during the second overtime.
Mensah connected with Toney for a three-yard touchdown, putting Miami ahead 41-35.
With college football overtime rules requiring a two-point conversion beginning in the second overtime, the Hurricanes turned to Toney for another critical play.
The sophomore received the ball and threw a successful conversion pass to Cooper Barkate, extending Miami's advantage to eight points.
Florida State had one final possession, but the Hurricanes' defense prevented the Seminoles from answering.
The performance reinforced Toney's growing importance to Miami's undefeated campaign.
Miami and Florida State Battle to 14-14 Halftime Tie
Miami opened the game aggressively, scoring on its first possession.
Mensah connected with Toney for a 30-yard gain before Mark Fletcher Jr. completed the drive with a seven-yard touchdown run.
Florida State responded early in the second quarter when Daniels found tight end Desirrio Riles for a 23-yard touchdown.
The Hurricanes regained the lead later in the quarter.
Mensah connected with Toney for a 14-yard touchdown pass, giving Miami a 14-7 advantage.
However, costly Miami penalties provided Florida State with favorable field position late in the half.
The Seminoles began a possession at Miami's 15-yard line following two personal fouls.
Daniels finished the opportunity with a two-yard touchdown run, tying the game 14-14 at halftime.
The opening half established the competitive tone of a rivalry matchup that would eventually require overtime for only the second time in series history.
Florida State Takes Third-Quarter Lead
Florida State carried its momentum into the second half.
Defensive back Ashlynd Barker intercepted Mensah in the end zone, ending the Miami quarterback's streak of 153 consecutive passes without an interception to begin his Hurricanes career.
The Seminoles' defense continued frustrating Miami, holding the Hurricanes scoreless on four consecutive possessions.
Florida State eventually capitalized offensively.
Daniels connected with Jayvan Boggs for a 26-yard gain before finding Quintrevion Wisner for a 28-yard touchdown reception.
The score gave Florida State its first lead at 21-14 with 4:09 remaining in the third quarter.
The Seminoles appeared positioned to deliver a major upset against the undefeated Hurricanes.
Miami Rallies Before Duce Robinson Forces Overtime
Miami responded in the fourth quarter behind Mallory.
The running back scored on a three-yard touchdown run to tie the game at 21.
The Hurricanes then recovered a Florida State fumble after Ethan O'Connor forced the ball loose and Xavier Lucas secured possession.
Miami capitalized with a 10-play, 61-yard touchdown drive that consumed more than six minutes.
Mensah connected with Elijah Lofton for a three-yard touchdown, giving the Hurricanes a 28-21 lead with 2:49 remaining.
Florida State needed just one play to answer.
Daniels found wide receiver Duce Robinson for a spectacular 75-yard touchdown, tying the contest at 28 and forcing overtime.
Robinson finished with five receptions for 113 yards and two touchdowns.
Miami Wins Double-Overtime Thriller 43-35
Florida State struck first in overtime when Daniels connected with Robinson for a 20-yard touchdown.
The score gave the Seminoles a 35-28 advantage.
Miami immediately answered.
Mallory broke free for a 25-yard touchdown run, tying the game at 35 and forcing a second overtime.
The Hurricanes then took control through Toney's decisive contributions.
Mensah found Toney for a three-yard touchdown before Toney connected with Barkate on the two-point conversion.
Miami led 43-35, leaving Florida State needing a touchdown and conversion to continue the contest.
The Seminoles nearly produced another dramatic response.
Daniels completed a fourth-and-21 pass for 36 yards that appeared to keep Florida State alive, but officials called the play back because of holding.
On the following attempt, Daniels launched a desperation pass into the end zone.
Miami defensive back Bryce Fitzgerald intercepted the pass, securing the victory after an official review.
Florida State disputed the final ruling, believing Robinson had possession of the football.
Nevertheless, the interception stood, ending the game and preserving Miami's undefeated season.
Darian Mensah and Ashton Daniels Deliver Strong Performances
Mensah completed 23 of 34 passes for 326 yards, three touchdowns and one interception.
Mallory provided Miami with a dependable rushing attack, finishing with 108 yards and two touchdowns.
Fletcher contributed 66 rushing yards and a touchdown.
For Florida State, Daniels completed 15 of 28 passes for 298 yards and four touchdowns while adding 31 rushing yards and another score.
His four passing touchdowns tied his career high.
Wisner contributed 63 rushing yards and 56 receiving yards, including a touchdown.
Barker led Florida State defensively with 13 tackles, two pass breakups and an interception.
Despite those performances, the Seminoles could not overcome Miami's execution in the second overtime.
Miami Strengthens Case for No. 1 Ranking
The Hurricanes' victory carried significance beyond their rivalry with Florida State.
With No. 1 Georgia losing to Auburn and No. 2 Notre Dame falling to BYU, Miami emerged as a potential candidate for the top position in the next AP Top 25 poll.
The results marked the first time since November 17, 2012, that the nation's top two teams lost on the same regular-season Saturday.
Miami remained undefeated at 6-0, strengthening its national championship aspirations.
Head coach Mario Cristobal emphasized his team's ability to overcome mistakes and remain focused on winning rather than potential changes in the rankings.
The Hurricanes have also won seven of their last 10 meetings with Florida State.
What's Next for Miami and Florida State?
Miami returns to Hard Rock Stadium on Saturday, October 24, to face Pittsburgh in another ACC matchup.
The Hurricanes will look to extend their undefeated record while maintaining their position among the nation's leading College Football Playoff contenders.
Florida State enters its second bye week before hosting Clemson on Saturday, October 31, at Doak Campbell Stadium.
For Miami, Saturday's victory represented another defining moment in its 2026 campaign.
Toney's extraordinary performance, Mensah's leadership and Fitzgerald's final interception combined to deliver a memorable rivalry victory that kept the Hurricanes undefeated.





Virginia Defeats Virginia Tech 3-1 Behind Becca Wight's 11 Kills, Extends Rivalry Win Streak to Nine




