Amber Aniston+ • September 28, 2025

No. 5 Pitt Overpowers No. 11 SMU in Four-Set Showdown

Panthers Extend Winning Streak at Home 


The Petersen Events Center in Pittsburgh was buzzing Sunday afternoon as the Panthers once again showed why they are among the nation’s elite. No. 5 Pitt extended its winning streak to 10 matches with a hard-fought four-set victory over No. 11 SMU, taking the match 25-20, 25-22, 26-28, 25-21. The result pushed Pitt’s record to 10-2 overall and 2-0 in ACC competition, while the Mustangs dropped to 8-4 and remain winless in conference play at 0-2. 


The star of the afternoon was none other than Olivia Babcock. The reigning National Player of the Year was in unstoppable form, registering a career-best 29 kills on .347 hitting while also posting a personal-high 17 digs. Babcock’s versatility—power at the net combined with defensive stability—proved to be the difference maker throughout the match. Setter Brooke Mosher was equally pivotal, notching 52 assists to fuel an offense that finished with a .310 hitting percentage, a mark that often spells victory against ranked opponents. 


Strong Start for the Panthers 


The opening set set the tone for what would become a competitive but ultimately Pitt-controlled match. After SMU grabbed an early 4-2 lead behind solid passing, Pitt responded with a decisive 5-0 run that put them ahead for good. The Panthers leaned on balanced scoring, with contributions from Babcock, Blaire Bayless, and middle blocker Ryla Jones. SMU attempted to close the gap late in the frame, but Bayless capped the set with a thunderous kill to secure a 25-20 win for Pitt. 


In the second set, Pitt once again jumped out quickly, building a 6-1 lead with Mosher’s precise distribution keeping SMU blockers guessing. The Mustangs clawed back within a single point at 20-19, thanks to aggressive swings from Malaya Jones and steady setting from Averi Carlson. Yet Pitt showed composure, responding with a pair of kills from Babcock and Bayless to finish off the set 25-22. The Panthers headed into intermission with a 2-0 cushion and appeared on the brink of another sweep. 


Mustangs Fight Back in Third 


SMU showed why it belongs among the nation’s top programs by storming back in the third set. The Mustangs fed off energy from the bench and relied heavily on Casey Batenhorst, whose jump serve created havoc for Pitt’s passers. A pair of consecutive aces gave SMU a 9-5 advantage and forced a Pitt timeout. 


While Babcock exploded for 13 kills in the third set alone, the Mustangs countered with timely blocking and scrappy defense from libero Reagan Zimmerman. Pitt earned a match point at 26-25, but SMU would not fold. Back-to-back kills from Natalia Newsome and Malaya Jones pushed the Mustangs ahead, and a Pitt hitting error sealed the 28-26 victory for SMU, extending the match to a fourth set and injecting drama into the afternoon. 


Babcock Finishes the Job 


The Panthers quickly regrouped in the fourth set, refusing to allow the Mustangs further momentum. Mosher spread the offense beautifully, finding Bayless on the left pin and Jones through the middle. Babcock continued her dominance, adding seven more kills in the frame. Pitt raced out to a 23-17 lead, but SMU responded with a late surge to cut it to 23-20. The rally was short-lived, however, as Babcock fittingly ended the match with her 29th kill to secure the 25-21 set win and a 3-1 overall triumph. 


Depth and Balance for Pitt 


Beyond the headline numbers from Babcock, Pitt received key contributions across the board. Bayless notched 12 kills at a .310 clip, Jones added seven blocks to anchor the net, and libero Cat Flood recorded 15 digs to stabilize the back row. The Panthers’ ability to combine firepower with defensive consistency showed why they continue to thrive in one of the nation’s toughest conferences. 


Mosher’s performance also deserves special mention. Her 52 assists marked a career high, but it was her court leadership—keeping hitters engaged and setting tempo after each long rally—that made the difference. Pitt finished the day with five players recording at least six kills, underscoring the balance in their offense. 


Mustangs Show Promise 


Though SMU left Pittsburgh without a win, the Mustangs demonstrated grit and flashes of brilliance that bode well for their season. Malaya Jones and Jadyn Livings paced the offense with 14 kills apiece, while Carlson tallied 48 assists and kept her hitters involved in every rotation. Middle blocker Favor Anyanwu also impressed with 10 kills on .529 hitting, showing efficiency that challenged Pitt’s block. 


Defensively, SMU hung tough against one of the nation’s most potent attacks, holding Pitt under .300 in two sets and forcing extended rallies that pushed the Panthers to the limit. The third-set comeback was evidence of the team’s competitive resolve. 


What It Means 


For Pitt, the victory was another notch in an already impressive season résumé. It marked the Panthers’ sixth win over a ranked opponent and extended their home winning streak at the Petersen Events Center to 16 matches, a run that dates back to 2019. The win also reinforced Pitt’s reputation as a championship contender capable of adjusting under pressure. 


For SMU, the loss dropped them to 0-2 in ACC play, but the Mustangs gained valuable experience competing in a hostile environment against one of the nation’s top-five teams. Their ability to stretch Pitt to four sets and steal momentum in the third highlighted the program’s growth and potential to make noise as the season progresses. 


Looking Ahead 


Pitt now turns its attention to a road trip to face Syracuse, aiming to keep its unbeaten ACC record intact. SMU heads back home to Dallas, where the Mustangs will host Georgia Tech on October 3 in search of their first conference win. Both teams remain firmly in the national conversation, and Sunday’s clash showcased the kind of high-level volleyball fans can expect as the ACC schedule heats up. 

ACC Football Championship Game 2026 scenarios graphic for the Week 12 title race
By Drew Rhoden • November 19, 2026
Miami can clinch an ACC championship game berth this weekend, and Wake Forest can too with help. The title game is Dec. 5, noon ET, on ABC, in Charlotte.
American Conference Football Championship 2026 graphic: three teams tied at 5-1, title game Dec. 5 on ABC
By Drew Rhoden • November 19, 2026
Memphis, UTSA, and North Texas are tied at 5-1 entering Week 12. The American Conference championship is Saturday, Dec. 5, at 8 p.m. ET, on ABC.
Georgia Tech vs Georgia basketball Friday preview graphic, 8 p.m. ET at McCamish
By Drew Rhoden • November 19, 2026
Georgia Tech and Georgia are both 5-0 heading into Friday's 8 p.m. ET game at McCamish Pavilion on ESPNU. Official times, records, and series history.
AP Top 25 Week 3 graphic: Florida stays No. 1 in the official college basketball poll
By Drew Rhoden • November 19, 2026
Florida stays No. 1 in the official AP Top 25 college basketball poll through Nov. 15, 2026. Full records, the biggest movers, and teams receiving votes.
Kimi Antonelli F1 World Champion graphic: the youngest title, with three races still to run
By Drew Rhoden • November 19, 2026
Kimi Antonelli is F1's youngest World Champion at 20 years and 68 days. Official standings after Brazil, and what's left in Las Vegas, Qatar, and Abu Dhabi.
CFP rankings graphic: Georgia stays No. 1 in the third official poll of 2026
By Drew Rhoden • November 19, 2026
The official CFP rankings keep Georgia at No. 1, with Utah, Alabama and UCLA in the top four. Here is what the third poll means for the 12-team field.
Las Vegas Grand Prix 2026 preview graphic for the Saturday night race on the Strip
By Drew Rhoden • November 19, 2026
The Las Vegas Grand Prix 2026 is Saturday, Nov. 21, at 8 p.m. local. Official standings after Brazil, the Strip circuit, and key storylines.
NCAA volleyball tournament 2026 graphic before the Nov. 29 selection show
By Drew Rhoden • November 19, 2026
Official dates for the Division I women's volleyball championship: selection show Nov. 29 on ESPN, semifinals Dec. 17 and the title Dec. 20 in San Antonio.
More Posts