No. 18 BYU Survives Arizona in Double Overtime to Stay Unbeaten
Cougars Overcome Weather Delay and Fourth-Quarter Deficit to Remain Perfect
TUCSON, Ariz. — The No. 18 BYU Cougars remained undefeated in dramatic fashion Saturday night, overcoming a lightning delay, a double-overtime battle, and a ten-point fourth-quarter deficit to defeat Arizona 33–27 at Arizona Stadium. The victory improved BYU to 6–0 overall and 3–0 in Big 12 play, marking the first time in program history the Cougars have opened back-to-back seasons with six consecutive wins.
Freshman quarterback Bear Bachmeier powered BYU’s comeback with 172 passing yards and 89 rushing yards, accounting for three total touchdowns. His seven-yard rushing score in the second overtime sealed the win after a grueling five-hour contest that tested both teams’ stamina and composure.
Running back LJ Martin turned in a career-best performance with 162 rushing yards and one touchdown, pacing an offense that produced 258 yards on the ground — the most Arizona has allowed in a game this season. Linebacker Siale Esera led BYU’s defense with a career-high 16 tackles as the Cougars held firm late to preserve the victory.
For Arizona (4–2, 1–2 Big 12), the loss was a heartbreaker. The Wildcats led 24–14 midway through the fourth quarter but were unable to hold off BYU’s late surge. Quarterback Noah Fifita threw for 219 yards and two touchdowns, while receiver Kris Hutson hauled in nine passes for 106 yards and a score.
Fast Start for the Cougars
BYU opened the game with precision and pace, dominating the early stages on both sides of the ball. The Cougars marched downfield on their second possession, with Martin bursting through the middle for a 28-yard touchdown that gave them a 7–0 lead midway through the first quarter.
Moments later, Bachmeier connected with wideout Parker Kingston over the middle for a 75-yard touchdown strike, extending the advantage to 14–0. The Cougars appeared in full control, executing crisp blocking schemes and converting both third-down attempts on the opening drives.
Arizona’s offense found rhythm late in the first quarter as Fifita began distributing the ball efficiently. A 14-play, 77-yard drive culminated in Chris Hunter’s 35-yard touchdown reception, trimming BYU’s lead to 14–7 early in the second quarter.
Just as the Wildcats gained momentum, play was halted by a lightning delay caused by the remnants of Hurricane Priscilla. The stoppage lasted more than 75 minutes and shifted the tone of the game entirely.
Arizona Takes Control After Delay
The extended delay seemed to benefit the home team. When play resumed, Arizona’s defense tightened, forcing BYU into consecutive punts. Fifita capitalized late in the half, leading an efficient two-minute drive capped by a touchdown pass to Hunter, giving Arizona its first lead at 17–14 heading into halftime.
BYU’s rushing attack, which dominated early, stalled under Arizona’s adjustments. The Wildcats’ front seven began winning battles at the line of scrimmage, limiting Martin’s space and disrupting Bachmeier’s rhythm.
Arizona extended its lead in the third quarter, capitalizing on BYU’s first turnover. Fifita orchestrated a balanced drive, mixing short completions with runs from Kedrick Reescano, who broke multiple tackles for a 36-yard touchdown run. The score gave the Wildcats a 24–14 advantage with just over 11 minutes to play, putting the Cougars in unfamiliar territory.
Bachmeier and the Cougars Battle Back
Facing their largest deficit of the season, BYU turned to its freshman quarterback. Bachmeier responded with a poised, methodical approach that showcased both his arm and legs.
On a crucial fourth-quarter possession, he led a 12-play, 75-yard drive, highlighted by two scrambles that kept the offense alive on third down. With less than 20 seconds remaining, Bachmeier rolled right and powered through defenders for a two-yard touchdown, tying the game at 24–24 and sending it to overtime.
BYU’s defense matched the intensity. Esera and linebacker Faletau Satuala combined for multiple key tackles on Arizona’s ensuing drives, including a stop at the one-yard line that prevented the Wildcats from reclaiming the lead earlier in the quarter. The defensive front, led by Cashius Howell and Isaiah Glasker, disrupted Fifita’s timing and limited explosive plays downfield.
First Overtime: Trading Blows
The opening overtime period mirrored the game’s dramatic swings. Both teams exchanged field goals — BYU’s Randy Bond converted from 38 yards, while Arizona’s Trey Smack answered with a 42-yarder to make it 27–27.
BYU appeared poised to end it in the first extra session, but a third-down pass from Bachmeier was deflected at the line. The Wildcats’ defense momentarily held firm, setting up a second overtime that would determine the outcome.
Second Overtime: Bachmeier Seals It
In the second overtime, BYU wasted no time asserting control. On third-and-four from the seven-yard line, Bachmeier called his own number, slicing through the middle for the go-ahead touchdown. The two-point conversion attempt was broken up, keeping the score 33–27 and leaving the door open for Arizona.
The Wildcats’ final drive ended in heartbreak. On fourth down, Fifita’s fade pass toward the back of the end zone slipped through receiver Javin Whatley’s hands, falling incomplete and sealing BYU’s sixth consecutive win.
As the Cougars celebrated, their defense — which had endured nearly 90 plays — walked off the field with another defining moment in a season built on resilience and balance.
Key Performances
Bachmeier’s leadership under pressure defined the night. The freshman finished with 261 total yards and three touchdowns, becoming the first BYU quarterback since 2014 to lead a double-digit fourth-quarter comeback. His mobility and decision-making were instrumental in sustaining drives during the Cougars’ late push.
Martin’s 162-yard outing marked the fifth 100-yard rushing game of his career and his third this season. The offensive line, led by Kingsley Suamataia, paved the way for 258 total rushing yards — BYU’s highest single-game total since joining the Big 12.
Defensively, Esera’s 16 tackles doubled his previous career high, while Glasker’s interception in the third quarter halted an Arizona drive deep in BYU territory. The defense also tallied seven tackles for loss and two takeaways, including Howell’s late-game fumble recovery that flipped momentum in the fourth quarter.
For Arizona, Fifita’s 219 passing yards and two touchdowns highlighted another efficient outing, but late pressure and dropped passes derailed potential scoring drives. Reescano’s 91 rushing yards and physical style gave the Wildcats balance early, while Hutson’s reliability in key situations kept the chains moving throughout the night.
Historical Context and What’s Next
The win cemented BYU’s place among college football’s most consistent programs under head coach Kalani Sitake, who secured his 75th career victory. It also marked the Cougars’ first overtime win since 2022, when they defeated Baylor 26–20 in Provo.
For BYU, the victory not only preserved an undefeated record but also secured bowl eligibility for the eighth time in the Sitake era. The Cougars will now prepare for their next major test — a home matchup against rival Utah on Saturday, Oct. 18.
Arizona, meanwhile, will look to regroup when it travels to Houston next weekend. Despite the loss, the Wildcats showed flashes of the offensive efficiency that fueled their early-season success.
Final Takeaway
Saturday night in Tucson offered a showcase of BYU’s character — a blend of grit, depth, and discipline that continues to define its ascent in the Big 12. Through lightning delays, a hostile crowd, and a double-overtime test, the Cougars proved once again why they belong among college football’s elite.
For a young quarterback like Bachmeier and a team determined to sustain perfection, the 33–27 victory wasn’t just another win — it was a defining moment in a season built on composure, belief, and execution








