NFL Owners Vote to Keep Eagles’ Controversial ‘Tush Push’ Alive for 2025 Season
Philadelphia’s Signature Play Survives League-Wide Scrutiny — For Now
The Philadelphia Eagles’ infamous “tush push” play — also nicknamed the “Brotherly Shove” — will remain legal for the 2025 NFL season after a closely contested vote failed to meet the threshold required for a ban. The outcome is a major win for the reigning Super Bowl champions and a blow to critics who believe the play gives the Eagles an unfair edge in short-yardage situations.
The proposal, submitted by the Green Bay Packers, needed approval from 24 of the NFL’s 32 team owners but fell just two votes short, with a 22-10 outcome. That means the league’s most polarizing and effective sneak play will continue — much to the frustration of some opposing coaches and defenders.
The Origin and Mechanics of the Play
The “tush push” is a quarterback sneak executed with supporting players — typically running backs or tight ends — pushing the quarterback forward from behind at the line of scrimmage. It’s most often used in goal-line or fourth-and-short scenarios, and no team has mastered it quite like the Eagles.
Fueled by quarterback Jalen Hurts’ powerful lower body — he reportedly squats over 600 pounds — and a dominant offensive line anchored by All-Pros like Lane Johnson and Jordan Mailata, the Eagles have converted the play at an 87% success rate, significantly above the league average of 71%.
League Debate: Strategy vs. Safety
Critics argue the play is almost unstoppable and lacks skill, turning what should be a strategic moment into a guaranteed gain for Philadelphia. The Packers’ revised proposal sought to ban any form of pushing or pulling of the ball carrier, citing concerns around competitive fairness and player safety. Violations would have resulted in a 10-yard penalty.
Supporters of the play, however, countered that injury data didn’t back the safety concerns. In fact, NFL officials confirmed there were no recorded injuries linked to the play during the 2024 season. Many saw the safety argument as a smokescreen for what was ultimately frustration with the Eagles' dominance.
The Eagles Fight Back
Leading the charge to preserve the play were Eagles owner Jeffrey Lurie and recently retired center Jason Kelce, who both spoke in defense of the play during the owners’ spring meetings. The team also launched a light-hearted social media campaign, celebrating the outcome with memes, slogans like “Push On,” and video montages of successful executions of the play.
The Eagles’ staff and players have long defended the “tush push” as a product of execution, timing, and discipline. Head coach Nick Sirianni and offensive coordinator Kevin Patullo have emphasized that mastering the play requires detailed coaching, not just brute strength.
A Broader Context
Since 2022, the Eagles have run the tush push over 100 times — more than one-third of all such attempts league-wide — and account for more than half of the NFL’s touchdowns using the technique. The Bills and Bears have also tried using it, but no one has come close to matching Philadelphia’s consistency or efficiency.
The play became so synonymous with the Eagles that some fans and analysts suspected the proposed ban had less to do with health and more to do with competitiveness. The Packers, who were eliminated by the Eagles in the 2024 playoffs following several critical tush push conversions, appeared especially motivated to push the issue forward.
Looking Ahead to 2025
The Eagles are set to face the Packers again in Week 10 during a Monday Night Football showdown — a game that now carries extra narrative weight. It's likely the tush push will feature prominently, serving as a symbol of Philadelphia’s strategic strength and the league's inability to legislate away a competitive advantage.
Even so, the debate may not be over. Competition Committee members have hinted that the topic could return in future league meetings. If enough momentum builds, the push to ban the push may yet succeed in the years to come.
The Bottom Line
For now, the Eagles retain one of their most effective offensive weapons. As long as the play remains within the rules — and as long as Philadelphia continues to run it better than anyone else — the “tush push” will remain a powerful part of the team’s identity.
In a sport where precision, timing, and physical dominance define success, the Eagles’ play doesn’t break football — it reinforces just how hard it is to be great.







